As a therapist who works with gay men in Chicago, I spend a lot of time thinking about language. Not just what we say in therapy rooms, but the words we use out in the world—especially in queer spaces like Halsted Street.
There’s a kind of shorthand that lives there. A glance, a look up and down, a word tossed casually into the air.
“Hot jock.”
It’s meant as a compliment. Most of the time, it lands that way. But it also carries more weight than people realize. I’ve heard some version of that phrase—along with “otter,” “twink,” “daddy,” “masc,” and plenty of others—come up again and again in therapy. Not because the words themselves are bad, but because of what they quietly do to identity, desire, and self-worth over time.
Why Gay Men Rely on Labels So Much
Gay male culture didn’t invent labels just for fun. Historically, we needed shorthand. Before dating apps, before visibility, coded language helped men find one another safely. Labels created recognition and belonging in a world that often didn’t offer either.
Even now, labels are efficient. On apps, at bars, on Halsted sidewalks, they help communicate attraction fast. And there’s nothing inherently wrong with that.
The issue is what happens when efficiency replaces curiosity.
Psychologically speaking, our brains love categories. Research shows we make snap judgments about others in milliseconds. In gay spaces—where desire, comparison, and visibility are heightened—those snap judgments often turn into identities.
What “Hot Jock” Really Signals
When someone says “hot jock,” they’re rarely just commenting on looks. They’re usually pointing to a whole bundle of traits we’ve been taught to value: an athletic or muscular body, youth or youth-adjacent energy, traditional masculinity, and a kind of “straight-passing” ease.
In therapy, I often hear men describe how powerful it felt to be associated with that image—and how anxious it became to maintain it.
Masculinity, in gay male culture, often functions like social currency. And like any currency, its value depends on the room you’re in and whether you’re still holding it.
Halsted Street as an Emotional Amplifier
Halsted Street is a mirror. It reflects back what gay culture is rewarding in any given moment. And because it’s public, social, and often alcohol-fueled, everything gets amplified.
Who’s noticed. Who’s ignored. Who gets called what.
For some men, that visibility is affirming. For others, it quietly reinforces a sense of “I don’t measure up.” Studies consistently show that gay men experience higher rates of body dissatisfaction than heterosexual men, and environments that emphasize appearance can intensify that gap.
That doesn’t mean Halsted is the problem. It means it’s a place where underlying dynamics become visible.
When Labels Start to Shrink Identity
I don’t see clients coming in saying, “I’m upset someone called me a hot jock.” What I hear instead sounds more like, “I don’t feel desirable anymore,” “I don’t know who I am outside my body,” “My partner doesn’t see me the way they used to,” or “I feel invisible in gay spaces now.”
Labels compress identity. They take a whole person and flatten them into a trait. And when that trait changes—as bodies, age, and life inevitably do—men can feel like they’ve lost more than a look. They feel like they’ve lost status, belonging, or worth.
On the other end of the spectrum are labels meant to sting. Age-based or appearance-based insults can cut deeply, especially in a culture that already struggles with aging and invisibility. I’ve written elsewhere about moments like being labeled an “old troll” at Pride, because those experiences tend to stay with people far longer than we expect.
How This Shows Up in Therapy With Gay Men
In gay men’s therapy, we often end up unpacking these labels gently, over time.
We look at questions like when you first learned what was desirable, which parts of yourself feel celebrated and which feel hidden, how much of your confidence is tied to how you’re perceived, and what happens to desire when safety and authenticity increase.
Research suggests that internalized appearance standards are linked to higher anxiety and depression in gay men. Therapy isn’t about rejecting desire or attraction. It’s about expanding identity so self-worth isn’t dependent on staying inside a narrow box.
This work becomes especially important in relationships, where partners may be grieving older versions of themselves or each other without realizing it.
Moving Beyond the Label Without Losing Desire
I don’t believe the answer is to get rid of labels entirely. They’re part of gay culture, and they can be playful, affirming, and connective. Terms like “hot otter,” for example, often carry warmth and affection rather than hierarchy, which I’ve explored in another post.
The goal isn’t to shame desire. It’s to loosen its grip on identity.
You can enjoy being seen without being reduced. You can want to be desired without being trapped by what made you desirable once. You can hold masculinity, softness, aging, and complexity at the same time.
That’s often the deeper work—learning how to be visible without performing.
A Final Thought
“Hot jock” on Halsted Street might sound like a passing comment. But like most shorthand in gay culture, it reveals a lot about what we value, what we fear losing, and how closely desire and identity are intertwined.
In my work at 2nd Story Counseling, I help gay men and other queer identities explore these dynamics with curiosity instead of judgment—so labels become something you can play with, not something that defines you.
RELATED POSTS:
