Anxiety and Depression: A Chicago Lakefront Paradox

As a therapist practicing in Chicago, I’ve noticed a pattern that might seem counterintuitive at first. Many of my clients who live in the most desirable lakefront neighborhoods—areas with stunning views, walkable streets, and abundant amenities—struggle with anxiety and depression at rates that often surprise them. They wonder: “I have everything I thought I wanted. Why do I feel this way?”

The answer isn’t simple, but it’s worth exploring. Living along Chicago’s lakefront offers undeniable advantages, yet it also comes with psychological stressors that differ significantly from suburban life.

The Sensory Overload Factor

Let me paint a picture of a typical night in Lakeview. You’re trying to fall asleep in your apartment on Sheffield, but the bar crowds from Wrigleyville are spilling onto the street below. The Red Line rumbles past on the elevated tracks every seven minutes. A siren wails down Clark. Someone’s blasting music from their car at the stoplight. At 2 AM, the street sweeper makes its pass. By 6:30 AM, the garbage trucks begin their rounds.

This isn’t occasional noise—it’s the soundtrack of daily life. Our nervous systems weren’t designed for this level of continuous input. In Edgewater, residents on Broadway or Sheridan deal with the constant bus traffic, the 6 AM construction starting on yet another condo conversion, the delivery trucks idling outside the Jewel on Ashland.

Over time, this chronic overstimulation can dysregulate our stress response, leaving us in a semi-activated state that feels like low-grade anxiety. Your body never fully relaxes because it can’t. There’s always another sound, another stimulus, another interruption.

In the suburbs, there’s literal and figurative space to decompress. The nervous system gets a break. That quiet isn’t just peaceful—it’s restorative in ways we don’t fully appreciate until we’ve lost it.

The CTA Factor

The CTA is both a blessing and a psychological burden. Yes, you can get anywhere without a car. But have you noticed how the constant calculations drain you? Is the Red Line running? Should I add twenty minutes because of delays? Will the bus show up, or should I just walk the fifteen blocks? The 36 Broadway is packed again—do I squeeze on or wait for the next one?

Then there’s the ride itself. Standing body-to-body with strangers. Someone’s playing music without headphones. The person next to you is having a mental health crisis, and you’re trying to be compassionate while also feeling unsafe. You’re hyper-vigilant in a way you don’t realize until you’re exhausted from a simple trip to Target on Clark and Diversey.

I have suburban clients who complain about their commutes, but there’s a psychological difference between sitting alone in your car and managing the unpredictable chaos of public transit twice a day, every day. One is boring; the other is depleting.

The Comparison Trap Intensified

Walk down Roscoe Street on a Saturday morning. The thirty-year-old couple renovating their vintage greystone. The neighbor who just made partner. The influencer shooting content outside the coffee shop on Southport. Everyone seems to be thriving, achieving, optimizing their lives.

In Wrigleyville, the bars are filled with people who look like they’re having the time of their lives. On Broadway in Edgewater, you see the runners with perfect form, the families who seem to have it all figured out. The comparison cycle is relentless because visible success is everywhere.

At the Jewel on Ashland and Bryn Mawr, you’re making careful choices about what you can afford while the person behind you is casually filling their cart. At the Target on Clark, you’re surrounded by people buying things that signal a life you thought you’d have by now.

In suburban communities, there’s often more diversity in life stages and career paths. The pediatrician lives next to the teacher next to the retiree. The comparison pressure, while still present, tends to be less intense and constant.

The Illusion of Community

You live in a three-flat on Kenmore or a high-rise on Sheridan. You recognize your neighbors’ faces, maybe even their dogs’ names, but do you actually know them? You pass people constantly—in the lobby, on the sidewalk, at the Mariano’s on Broadway—yet feel profoundly alone.

The transience of urban life means friendships can feel surface-level or constantly in flux. People move to different neighborhoods, take jobs in other cities, or you simply lose touch because coordinating schedules in the city requires so much effort. Meeting for coffee becomes a three-week text thread about availability.

Suburban life often provides more natural community infrastructure—block parties, school connections, backyard conversations over the fence. These weaker ties matter more than we realize for mental health. They create a sense of belonging and casual social support that can buffer against depression.

The Wrigleyville Weekend Effect

If you live near Wrigley Field, you know the psychological tax of game days and weekend nights. Your neighborhood becomes someone else’s party. The streets are impassable. The noise is inescapable. You can’t find parking near your own home. You feel like a hostage to other people’s good time.

Even if you love the Cubs, there’s something exhausting about your home never quite feeling like a sanctuary. You’re always accommodating, always adjusting, always planning around events that have nothing to do with your actual life.

The Pace and Productivity Pressure

Urban Chicago operates at a different tempo. There’s an implicit expectation to be always “on”—working late, networking, optimizing your time. Why go straight home when there’s a work event in River North? Why rest when you could be at that networking thing in Lincoln Park? The city rewards hustle, and that can seep into your identity. Rest feels like falling behind.

I see clients who can’t remember the last time they felt truly relaxed, who’ve forgotten how to simply be rather than constantly do. The burnout is real, and the suburban rhythm, with longer commutes that create boundaries and weekends that feel genuinely separate from work, can provide psychological breathing room.

Access to Nature (Or Lack Thereof)

Yes, the Lakefront Trail is beautiful. But walking on concrete beside Lake Michigan isn’t the same as being immersed in nature. You’re still surrounded by runners competing for space, cyclists whizzing past, construction noise from Lake Shore Drive. Research consistently shows that time in green spaces—trees, grass, natural environments—reduces cortisol and improves mood.

Where’s your access to actual nature in Lakeview or Edgewater? Margate Park is nice, but small. Lincoln Park offers trees, but you’re sharing them with thousands of others. Suburban residents have yards, forest preserves, and the psychological benefits of genuine solitude in green space.

The Grocery Store Stress

It’s Saturday afternoon, and you need groceries. The Jewel on Ashland is a zoo. The Target on Clark has lines wrapped around the store. The Mariano’s parking lot on Broadway is a nightmare. Just getting food—a basic human need—becomes a test of patience and stress tolerance.

You’re navigating crowded aisles, dealing with out-of-stock items, and then hauling bags back to your apartment because you don’t have a car. Or you drove, and now you’re circling for parking, adding another twenty minutes to a simple errand.

In the suburbs, you pull into a spacious parking lot, shop at a less-crowded store, load your car, and drive home. It’s boring, but it’s not triggering your stress response three times a week.

The Financial Stress Weight

Your rent on a one-bedroom on Halsted or Sheridan is $2,000-$2,800. Parking is another $200-$300 if you have a car. That cocktail in Wrigleyville is $16. The yoga class is $35. Even high earners feel the squeeze.

That translates to financial anxiety that hums in the background—Can I afford to stay here? Am I saving enough? Should I be doing better?—that adds to baseline stress levels. You’re spending more to live with more stress, and that paradox weighs on you.

What This Means for You

If you’re struggling with anxiety or depression in Lakeview, Edgewater, or Wrigleyville, know that your environment is a legitimate factor. You’re not weak or ungrateful for finding city life challenging. Your nervous system is responding rationally to real stressors.

That doesn’t mean you need to move to the suburbs. But it does mean you might need to be more intentional about:

Creating genuine quiet time and finding pockets of calm in your routine
Building deeper community connections rather than accumulating acquaintances
Setting boundaries around work and productivity expectations
Seeking out actual nature regularly—drive to the forest preserves, visit the lakefront early morning when it’s empty
Examining whether your living situation aligns with your values or just your idea of success
Planning around the chaos (grocery shopping on weekday mornings, avoiding game days)

The grass isn’t always greener in the suburbs either—different environments create different challenges. But understanding how your environment shapes your mental health is the first step toward making choices that truly serve your wellbeing. If you’re facing a major life transition like deciding whether to stay in the city or move, working through this decision with a therapist can be invaluable.

If you’re feeling the weight of these urban stressors, therapy can help you develop strategies to navigate them. Sometimes we can’t change our environment, but we can change how we respond to it—and sometimes that’s exactly the shift we need.

—

See our Chicago Lakeview Counseling page for more information on therapy services.